Author: admin

You will be encouraged to watch multiple short documentaries listed below, but you will only choose ONE of these texts to focus your essay on. 
Scholarly Texts:
Laura Bolin Carroll – “Backpacks vs Briefcases: Steps Towards Rhetorical Analysis”
Christine Photinos & Ramie Tateishi – “Rhetorical Analysis of Film – Elements of Film”
Short Documentary Options:
Kelsie Moore – “The Gray Area” (17 minutes)
Scott Farris & Meg Griffiths – “Into the Circle”(17 Minutes)
Daniel Lambroso – “American Scar” (14 minutes)
The Writing Task:
In an organized and focused essay, identify the central argument of a short documentary film and provide an analysis of the rhetorical strategies used by the filmmaker that persuade the audience to consider that argument. 
Criteria for Success:
Length: Essay contains four (4) full pages of writing (not including the Works Cited Page).
Format: Use of MLA Formatting and Works Cited Page. (See the MLA Style Guide for more detailed examples/instructions). 
Source Usage:
Detailed summaries, descriptions, and/or use of quotations from the documentary film (with proper citations). 
Use of direct quotations from Carroll and Photinos & Tateishi to define, contextualize, and support the analysis. You can use additional resources you have found on your own, but these will not count towards the source usage requirements, and you will need to contextualize and cite the sources appropriately. 
Focus: While you are being asked to summarize the central idea of the text, the primary focus of this essay should be on analyzing the rhetoric used within the text. 
See rubric (on the Essay 1 Submission Page) for more specific grading criteria.
The documentary I choose was into the circle 

Guidelines for Literary Analysis
In this essay you should combine your practice responding and analyzing short stories with support derived from research. So far, in the discussion boards, we have practiced primarily formal analysis—your own interpretations based on the text of a short story.  Now I want you to practice integrating research into your discussion of a short story.  For this essay you will write a literary analysis that incorporates research.  Refer to the readings in this unit to help you get started.
Choose the story you will write about from the short stories located in the folder accompanying these instructions on eCampus.  I recommend that you read several of the stories and then pick one that you want to explore further.
To help guide you, you can choose one of the approaches explained in the “Approaches to Literary Analysis” located at the bottom of this document. Each approach will require research, and that research should provide the context in which you present your own ideas and support your thesis.
While I am asking you to conduct outside research, do not lose sight of the primary text to which you are responding—the story!  Your research should support your interpretations of the story. Be sure that your thesis is relevant to the story and that you quote generously from the story.
Finally, take some time to view the documents in the folder “Resources for Literary Analysis” in this unit. That folder includes information on how to begin your research as well as sample essays.
Purpose:  critical analysis, close reading, writing from sources
Length: 3-4 pages, approx 900 – 1200 words
Documentation:  Minimum of 4 sources required.  One source will be the story you are writing about.  You will then need at least 3 secondary sources.  All of them should be documented in MLA format. (Note: review the material in “finding and evaluating sources” to help you choose relevant and trustworthy sources.)
You will be evaluated on the quality of your interpretation as well as how well you use external sources.  I want to see that you can locate relevant sources and quote, paraphrase and summarize without plagiarizing.  Remember, any unique idea must be credited, even if you put it in your own words.
Below are some topic examples.  I do not require you to choose one of these topics.  They are just here to give you an idea of the type of approaches that will work for this essay.
1.   Philosophical analysis: How do the stories by Jean Paul Sartre and Albert Camus reflect the philosophy of existentialism?  
2.   Socio/cultural analysis:  What opinion about marriage and gender roles does Hemingway advance in “The Short Happy Life of Francis Macomber”? 
3.  Historical analysis: What social dilemmas faced by African Americans in the 1960s might have inspired Toni Cade Bambara to write “The Lesson”?
4.  Biographical analysis:  What events in Salman Rushdie’s life might have influenced the events in “At the Auction of the Ruby Slippers”?
5. Psychological analysis:  How is John Cheever’s “The Swimmer” a metaphor for the psychology of addiction?
Approaches to Literary Analysis
Formal analysis – This type of analysis focuses on the formal elements of the work (language, symbolism, plot, character, setting) in an effort to explain how the story functions. It is concerned with the parts of the text and how those parts fit together to create meaning.  Outside information such as the author’s background and historical events are generally not referenced in formalist criticism. A formal analysis conceives of the literary work as a self-contained experience. If you choose this approach you will need to research scholarly interpretations of your selected story and include those as part of the conversation.
Historical analysis- This type of analysis uses historical context to understand the work. Many 20 th century stories can be best understood within the framework of major events: Industrialization, The Holocaust, WWII, The Great Depression, The Civil Rights Movement, feminism, etc.  A historical analysis will “base interpretations on the interplay between the text and historical contexts.”
” a piece of literature is shaped by the time period in which it was written and thus must be examined and interpreted in the context of that time period. This theory attempts to tie the characters, events and language in a piece of literature to events from the time period in which it was written. ”
If you choose this approach for your literary analysis, you should be well aware of the major events of the time period.
Biographical analysis – This type of analysis uses the author’s life as a starting point for interpreting the story. The belief is that it is necessary to know about the author and the political, economical, and sociological context of his times in order to truly understand his works.  How do the themes present in the story reflect the concerns and experiences of the author?  In this approach there may be considerable overlap with historical analysis.  That’s ok-they are not mutually exclusive.
Sociological analysis (cultural criticism) –  This type of analysis interprets the story in term of social structures:  class, race, gender, culture, nationality or economics. Feminist criticism, postcolonial criticism, Marxist criticism, etc. all fall into this category. It can also overlap with historical analysis.  For example, a Marxist criticism of Catcher in the Rye might claim that Holden’s depression is derived from material wealth and social inequality.
Philosophical  analysis:   This approach uses a philosophical framework from which to approach the work.  The belief is that the larger purpose of literature is to teach morality and to probe philosophical issues. Existentialism is a common philosophy that find roots in literature, particularly in that of Sartre and Camus.  Here are some questions to ask if you are interested in this approach.
·   What religious or ethical beliefs does the text deal with directly?  Are any religions or philosophies mentioned specifically in the text?
·   What religious or ethical beliefs or philosophies does the author seem to favor?  How can you tell?
·   What religious or ethical beliefs or philosophies does the author seem to disfavor? 
·   What behaviors do the characters display that the author wants us to think are “right”? 
Psychological Analysis:   This approach uses theories of human behavior as a means of analyzing the story. Psychological critics view works through the lens of psychology. They look either at the psychological motivations of the characters or of the authors themselves, although the former is generally considered a more respectable approach. Most frequently, psychological critics apply Freudian psychology to works, but other approaches (such as a Jungian approach) also exist.
·   Are there any specific psychologists or psychological theories mentioned in the text?  In what ways?
·   What theories of human behavior does the writer seem to believe?  How can you tell?
·   What theories of human behavior does the writer seem to reject?  How can you tell?
·   In what ways do the structure and organization of the text indicate the writer’ s beliefs about the workings of the mind?
Thesis Templates for Literary Analysis
Formal analysis
The author conveys the theme of _____________________ through the use of _______________ and ________________.
The central conflict in the story is  _________________________ and this conflict is intensified by the author’s use of ____(literary element)___________ and ______(literary element)____________.
Historical Analysis
The __________________________ (historical event) provides a framework for understanding the theme of ___________________ in the story.
Biographical Analysis
The story can be read as a metaphor for the author’s own experience with _____________________.
Psychological Analysis
Through the main character, this story demonstrates the common psychological problem of _________________.
Sociological Analysis
The author wrote  this story to teach readers about the injustices of ________________________ for  _____________________ people. 
The real villain in the story is the cultural expectation, common in the 20th century,  that ___________________.
Philosophical Analysis
This story illustrates the central dilemma posed by the philosophy of __________________.