The Flawed Logic of Punishment and Disadvantage: A Critique of Boonin’s Argument on Restitution In his article “The Punishment and Disadvantage Argument for Restitution,” philosopher David Boonin argues that

Punishment and Disadvantage : Criticize an argument.  First, present the argument you wish to criticize. It can be taken from Boonin or Cholbi on restitution, Lewis, or Shelby. You should analyze the argument – explain the conclusion to be established and the reasoning that supports it. Be as charitable as possible. Then, carefully explain how the argument goes wrong. Does it rely on weak premises? Is there a devastating counterargument it fails to address?  The criticism should be your own, not one that is found in the reading. 
Make sure to address at least one possible response to your objection. 
Finally, briefly discuss the stakes of your criticism: does it invalidate the author’s point in its entirety, or does it merely require modification of the argument?